KING TUT KILLED BY A HIPPO ON A HUNTING TRIP?
A new study shows that Tutankhamun, Egypt's famous "boy-king" who died around the age of 18, suffered a "massive crushing tearing injury to his chest" that likely would have killed him.
X-rays and CT scans have previously shown that the pharaoh's heart, chest
wall, the front part of his sternum and adjacent ribs, are missing. In
Ancient Egypt the heart was like the brain and removing it was something
that was not done. "The heart, considered the seat of reason, emotion, memory and personality, was the only major organ intentionally left in the body," writes Dr. Robert Ritner in the book Ancient Egypt.
The new research was done by Dr. Benson Harer, a medical doctor with an Egyptology background, who was given access to nearly 1700 CT scan images of Tut that were taken by a team of Egyptian scientists in 2005. Dr. Zahi Hawass, head of the Egyptian Supreme Council of Antiquities, gave permission for the work.
It has been suggested that tomb robbers, operating sometime between 1925 and 1968, may have stolen the heart and chest bones. The new research shows that while robbers stole some of Tut's jewelery they didn't take the body parts. Instead they were lost due to a massive chest injury Tut sustained while he was still alive.
This isn't the only medical problem Tut had. In 2005 a team of researchers reported that he had a broken leg and earlier this year an article in the Journal of the American Medical Association revealed that Tut suffered from malaria, something that may have contributed to his death.
Harer's work was published in the journal Bulletin of the Egyptian Museum. It was also presented last spring at a conference organized by the American Research Center in Egypt (ARCE). This Thursday Harer was in Canada, giving his findings at the University of Toronto.
Harer's research indicates that while Tut's jewelery was certainly stolen, the chest bones were already long gone.
The CT scans show, in high-resolution, the edge of what is left of Tut's rib bones. Dr. Harer said that "the ribs are very neatly cut" and could not have been chopped off by modern day thieves. "The ribs were cut by embalmers and not by robbers."
More proof that Tut suffered a major chest injury is found in the technique that Tut's embalmers used to take out his intestines, liver and stomach. In Ancient Egypt those organs were removed after death and put into canopic jars (video: King Tut's canopic shrine and jars introduced).
Harer said that the embalmers used a "transverse incision" which was cut
into Tut and went from his umbilicus (his navel), towards the spine. They
"took out the organs below the diaphragm," he said. However "they did not go
through the diaphragm to extract the lungs - the chest was gaping open, they
could just lift them out directly." Harer says he has never seen another royal mummy cut into this way. "Tut is the only upscale mummy I know that had a transverse incision."
There's more evidence that Tut's chest, including the skin, had been gouged away while he was still alive. When the first autopsy on Tut was done in 1925, it revealed that he had been stuffed like a turkey, filled with what Howard Carter called a "mass of linen and resin, now of rock-like hardness."
One possibility that Dr. Harer ruled out is that of a chariot accident. "If he fell from a speeding chariot going at top speed you would have what we call a tumbling injury - he'd go head over heels. He would break his neck. His back. His arms, legs. It wouldn't gouge a chunk out of his chest."
Instead, at his Toronto lecture, Harer brought up another, more exotic
possibility - that Tut was killed by a hippo.
It's not as far out an idea as it sounds, hippos are aggressive, quick and territorial animals, and there is an artifact in Tut's tomb which appears to show him hunting one of them.
It would also explain why there is no account of Tut's death since being
killed by a hippo would be a pretty embarrassing way for a pharaoh to die.
"Hippos kill more people than any other animal, they are the most lethal
animal in Africa (if not) the world," said Harer. "The victim suffers
massive tearing injury and can actually be cut in half." Medical reports
indicate that "even though they are running away from the hippo they
typically suffer a frontal wound."
In Tut's case, if the hippo charged, his entourage may not have been able to
get to him in time. "If he did have a club foot (as a recent medical report
suggests) it would make him the slowest person getting out of the way - the
easiest person for the hippo to get."
Tut may not have even been hunting a hippo. "It may have been that he was
fowling in the marsh, just got in the wrong area, and the hippo attacked
Still, it's tempting to imagine Tut trying to hunt a hippo. Despite his club
foot and malaria, it's enticing to believe that the teenage pharaoh decided
to hunt one of the most dangerous animals in the world. If his goal was to
increase his fame then he succeeded far beyond expectations, in death
becoming the most famous Egyptian ruler who ever lived.